What saving looks like
Say you set aside $55 a month, about the price of a typical plan. After one year you have $660. After three years, $1,980.
That covers a water heater, if it waits three years to fail. It doesn't cover a furnace ($3,000 to $8,000) or central AC ($3,500 to $7,500), especially if one of them goes in year one.
What a home warranty looks like
Instead of saving, you pay the monthly plan price and a flat service fee, roughly $65 to $125, when something breaks. If the furnace fails in month two, you pay the service fee and the plan covers the repair or replacement up to the coverage limit.
| If this breaks in year one | Saving $55/month | Home warranty |
|---|---|---|
| Water heater ($1,200 to $3,000) | Short $540 to $2,340 | One service fee |
| Furnace ($3,000 to $8,000) | Short $2,340 to $7,340 | One service fee |
| Central AC ($3,500 to $7,500) | Short $2,840 to $6,840 | One service fee |
| Nothing breaks | You keep $660 | You paid for peace of mind |
Coverage limits and exclusions apply, and they're explained when you enroll.
Which one wins for you
Saving can make sense if your furnace, AC and water heater are under 5 years old and you already have several thousand dollars set aside for emergencies.
A home warranty usually wins if your major systems are 10 years old or more, you live on a fixed income, or one big repair would wipe out your emergency fund. That describes most seniors in older homes.
Not sure where you stand? Our home repair cost calculator shows which of your systems are near the end of their life and what replacing them would cost.